Features

Personal Cleansers

September 3, 2008

More marketers are trying to develop mild cleaners that are free of sulfates. This article explains how to do it.

Sulfate-Free Personal Cleansers



More marketers are trying to develop mild cleaners that are free of sulfates. This article explains how to do it.



By Shoaib Arif
Pilot Chemical Co.
Cincinnati, OH



There are many different formulas to cleanse hair and skin, but there are only a few price points. The three categories that classify sulfate-free formulas for personal cleansing products such as hair shampoo, body wash, liquid hand soap and facial cleanser are:
    • Economy formulas based on alpha olefin sulfonates;
    • Medium grade formulas based on sulfosuccinate, betaine and/or amine oxide and
    • Premium formulas based on higher priced specialty surfactants.

Economy Formula



Economy sulfate-free formulations can use sodium C14-16 alpha olefin sulfonates as a primary surfactant. It is a low cost, high foaming anionic surfactant. These formulations can also incorporate alkanolamides and betaines as a secondary surfactant to provide mildness, foam stability and viscosity-building characteristics.
   
A simple and economic starting formula for a plain shampoo can be as follows.


Formula 1: Shampoo


Ingredients                                    % Wt


Water                                      q.s. to 100
Sodium alpha olefin sulfonate     30.0
Cocamide DEA                                 4.0
Sodium chloride                                4.0
Preservative, perfume and dye        q.s.
Citric acid                                    to pH 5.5
Viscosity:                                        3200 cp.
   
Cocamidopropyl betaine can improve the mildness and also the viscosity of the product. A desirable viscosity in the range of 7000 cp to 28,000 cp can be achieved by adding various amounts of betaine to this shampoo formula, while reducing the corresponding amount of water to keep the formula as 100%. An addition of 3% betaine to the formula will increase the viscosity to about 7000 cp., 5% betaine will take the viscosity to 14,000 and 10% will raise it to about 28,000 cp.
   
Formula 1 uses sodium chloride to increase viscosity. Ammonium chloride tends to build higher viscosities in most AOS based formulas than sodium chloride. The pH of the product must be lower than 7.0 in order to minimize the chances of ammonia release. Whereas 4% sodium chloride used in the shampoo formula with 10% additional betaine will give a viscosity of 28,000 cp., 4% ammonium chloride added in place of 4% sodium chloride will boost the viscosity to about 40,000 cp.
   
Let us also compare the viscosity building performance of the three commonly used alkanolamides, namely cocamide DEA, oleamide DEA  and cocamide MEA. In the shampoo formula with 10% betaine, the viscosity is 28,000. If we replace the cocamide DEA with cocamide MEA the viscosity will jump to about 52,000 whereas oleamide DEA will take the viscosity all the way up to 68,000 cp.

Medium Grade Formulas



Sulfosuccinates, betaines and amine oxides are somewhat lower cost materials among the specialty surfactants used in sulfate-free personal cleansing formulas. These are also comparatively mild surfactants with good foaming and viscosity-building properties. Their foaming capabilities do not match that of the high foaming alkyl sulfates or alkyl ether sulfates like sodium/ammonium lauryl and lauryl ether sulfates. However, that is why one must use comparatively higher total active surfactant load when formulating with the previously mentioned non-sulfated surfactants. A wide variety of thickeners are available to build the viscosity of a personal cleanser formula based on sulfosuccinate, betaine and/or amine oxide. To compare the viscosity-building performance of various thickeners we have put together the following sulfate-free formula.

Formula 2: Shampoo Without Viscosity Builders

Ingredients                                        % Wt


Disodium laureth sulfosuccinate    30.0
Cocamidopropyl betaine                  10.0   
Lauramine oxide                                10.0
Sodium chloride                                    4.0
Preservative, perfume and dye           q.s.
Water                                                 to 100%
   
To improve the minimal viscosity of formula 2, the following thickening chemistries were evaluated. The performance evaluation of these viscosity builders utilized a 4% (as is) addition rate to formula 2. Table 1 illustrates the viscosity building results of these thickeners.
 

 
A viscosity of 5000-12,000 cp. is achievable using the thickening systems shown above. The combination of HMPC and PEG-150DS gives the highest viscosity, is amide and DEA free and may be the most economical thickening system except for oleamide DEA. The high degree of ethoxylation in these thickening systems may also cut down the irritation of the formula and increase mildness. The thickeners listed above, in particular the last four, will also help provide the body, creamy and soft lather and pleasant after feel. 
   
Additional thickeners were also utilized to build viscosity of formula 2. The viscosity responses are in Table 2.



Premium Grade Formulas



Premium grade sulfate-free personal cleansers utilize specialty surfactants, most of which are naturally derived, biodegradable and mild. The surfactants used in premium grade are comparatively higher cost materials than the ones in economy or premium grade formulas. Table 3 depicts a wide variety of formulas and viscosities. Another set of formulas based on mild, biodegradable surfactants with rich, creamy lather and soft after feel are listed in Table 4, showing the viscosity building properties of various thickeners. 


   


The final two formulas (Table 5) use ultra mild surfactants as additives to provide mild and eco-friendly products that are sulfate- and amide-free.



In conclusion, the main objective in formulating sulfate-free personal and pet cleansers is to choose the right surfactants and the appropriate thickener system which complement each other and provide an optimum cost/performance effective formulation.


The information contained herein is provided in good faith as a starting guideline to formulators and is based on the study in Pilot’s laboratories and the work of others. Pilot Chemical Company makes no warranties, expressed or implied, as to the accuracy of the information contained herein. Nothing contained herein grants or extends a license or permission in connection with patents of Pilot Chemical Company or others.

About the Author



Shoaib Arif is the applications and technical service manager, home and personal care products, at Pilot Chemical Co., Cincinnati, OH. Previously, he was technology manager at Degussa Goldschmidt, Hopewell, VA. He has also worked in surfactant applications for home and personal care products at Noveon, Witco and Olin Chemicals. He has more than 30 years of experience in the home and personal care applications. For most of his career, Mr. Arif has been involved in the development of new and innovative formulations and applications for raw materials, particularly surfactants. He has authored many articles for technical magazines and journals and holds several patents.


blog comments powered by Disqus
  • Electric Slide

    Electric Slide

    Melissa Meisel, Associate Editor||February 3, 2016
    Skin care devices bring anti-aging to the next level

  • Crowning Glory

    Crowning Glory

    Christine Esposito , Associate Editor||February 3, 2016
    Celebrity stylists and experts from leading hair care brands talk about the ingredients and formats driving the styling sector.

  • Innovation On Display

    Melissa Meisel, Associate Editor||February 3, 2016
    P&G Beauty Digital Studio showcases new products for 2016

  • Testing for Sustainable Preservatives

    Adam P. Byrne, William Michael Hart-Cooper, Kaj Johnson, Larry H. Stanker, Dominic W. S. Wong, William J. Orts||January 4, 2016
    A rapid, inexpensive and qualitative protocol for determining microbial growth inhibition.

  • Burgeoning Beauty

    Burgeoning Beauty

    Melissa Meisel, Associate Editor||January 4, 2016
    A look at trailblazers for 2016 and beyond.

  • Looking Great, Even at 70!

    Tom Branna, Editorial Director||January 4, 2016
    The Society of Cosmetic Chemists marked its 70th anniversary during the annual meeting in New York last month.

  • It’s All About Teamwork

    It’s All About Teamwork

    Melissa Meisel , Associate Editor||January 4, 2016
    Collaboration was the theme of the Consumer Specialty Products Association 2015 annual meeting.

  • Making Sense of Smells

    Making Sense of Smells

    Tom Branna, Editorial Director||January 1, 2016
    Household product perfumery is more complex than ever, with a variety of notes obtained from many different sources.

  • Pod Nation

    Pod Nation

    Christine Esposito, Associate Editor||January 1, 2016
    Laundry detergent sales remain steady, but where consumers are spending their money and how they’re cleaning clothes is chan

  • Innovator to the End

    Innovator to the End

    Tom Branna, Editorial Director||December 2, 2015
    After nearly 40 years in the industry, Kevin Gallagher is set to retire from Croda.

  • In-Cosmetics Paris Has Sights on US

    In-Cosmetics Paris Has Sights on US

    Imogen Matthews , In-Cosmetics||December 2, 2015
    Market focus is on the USA.

  • Actives, Not Words

    Actives, Not Words

    Tom Branna , Editorial Director||December 2, 2015
    Today’s active skin care ingredients provide a host of benefits to the skin.

  • Silent Partners

    Silent Partners

    Christine Esposito, Associate Editor||December 2, 2015
    I&I suppliers are behind-the-scenes, but critical partners that help keep businesses running and consumers safe.

  • Cleansing Conditioners

    Cleansing Conditioners

    Denise Costrini and Christophe Toumit , Croda Personal Care North America||December 2, 2015
    Relying on consumer data, Croda researchers detail the drivers behind these successful formulas.

  • Trading Up

    Trading Up

    Melissa Meisel , Associate Editor||December 2, 2015
    Today’s shampoos & conditioners feature indulgent ingredients.

  • Just Wild About Harry’s Cosmeticology

    Just Wild About Harry’s Cosmeticology

    Tom Branna, Editorial Director||November 2, 2015
    The ninth edition, edited by Meyer Rosen, has been expanded and improved with an emphasis on the future of the industry.

  • Lush Is Flush with Novel Ideas

    Lush Is Flush with Novel Ideas

    Tom Branna, Editorial Director||November 2, 2015
    New products are the lifeblood of every company. Lush will launch more than 200 of them.

  • Davids and Goliaths

    Davids and Goliaths

    Christine Esposito, Associate Editor||November 2, 2015
    Big brands dominate the oral care category, but a cadre of smaller players vie for customers looking for alternatives.

  • What Do You Mean by Clean?

    What Do You Mean by Clean?

    Tom Branna, Editorial Director||November 2, 2015
    Household cleaning has undergone many changes over the years and more are on the way, as suppliers develop novel ingredients.

  • Falling Ahead

    Falling Ahead

    Christine Esposito, Associate Editor||November 2, 2015
    Juice sales have been driving growth as the fine fragrance category heads into the holiday season.

  • A Fresh Take

    A Fresh Take

    Melissa Meisel, Associate Editor||November 2, 2015
    Today’s soaps and shower products do more than just cleanse—they solve skin quandaries, are portable or even look whimsical!

  • Beauty Connection: a Platform for the Future

    Beauty Connection: a Platform for the Future

    November 2, 2015
    Happi spoke to Frédéric Boned, senior director global marketing and innovation for personal care at DSM, and David Paxton, global consumer and market insight manager, about the company’s new Beauty Connection platform and how market and consumer insights are incorporated into DSM’s innovation strategy.

  • Contract Manufacturing/Private Label Directory

    Contract Manufacturing/Private Label Directory

    October 1, 2015
    Our directory is your source to find a manufacturer to get your product to market.

  • Winner Unmasked

    Winner Unmasked

    October 1, 2015
    Laneige’s Water Sleeping Mask takes home top honors as Happi’s first Anti-Aging Product of the Year.

  • A Design for Living

    A Design for Living

    Tom Branna, Editorial Director||October 1, 2015
    Cornell McBride Sr. has had a range of successes during his 40-plus years in the hair care business.