• Login
    • Join
  • Subscribe Free
    • Magazine
    • eNewsletter
    Checkout
    • Magazine
    • News
    • Formulary
    • Exclusives
    • Top Companies
    • Raw Materials
    • End-User
    • Packaging
    • Directories
    • Events
    • Jobs
    • More
  • Magazine
  • News
  • Formulary
  • Exclusives
  • Top Companies
  • Raw Materials
  • End-User
  • Packaging
  • Directories
  • Events
  • Jobs
  • Current / Back Issues
    Features
    Columns
    Editorial
    Digital Edition
    eNewsletter Archive
    Our Team
    Editorial Guidelines
    Subscribe Now
    Advertise Now
    Top Features
    A Conversation with the Responsible Flushing Alliance

    Nice-Pak Meets Consumer Demands

    Wipes Manufacturers Meet Demand Surge

    Home Care Wipes: Sustainability in Sharper Focus as Cleaning Frenzy Simmers Following Pandemic

    Formulating with Alternatives In Personal Care Products
    Online Exclusives
    Association News
    Breaking News
    Financial News
    Industry News
    International
    Marketing News
    New Products
    News Front
    Packaging News
    Patents
    Personnel
    Regulations
    Snapshots
    Top News
    Live From Shows
    Top News
    Former L’Oréal Exec Joins Glossier

    Evonik Highlights Solutions for Malodor Reduction

    P&G Emphasizes Small Actions at Home To Be More Sustainable

    L'Oréal's Sales Jump on Gains in China and E-Commerce

    PCPC Virtual Summit Features Legal & Regulatory Conference
    Blog
    Online Exclusives
    Infographics
    Podcasts
    Whitepapers
    Videos
    Expert's Opinion
    HappiTV
    eBook
    Surveys
    International Top 30 Report
    Top 50 Report
    Top Companies
    45. Spartan Chemical

    23. Oriflame

    38. Monat Global

    28. John Paul Mitchell Systems

    13. Amway
    Actives
    Functional Ingredients
    Pigments
    Polymers
    Preservatives
    Surfactants

    L'Oréal's Sales Jump on Gains in China and E-Commerce

    Reckitt Seeks Germ-Killing Innovations

    Mariano Puig Planas Dies at 93

    Videobite: Innospec's Answer to the 1,4-Dioxane Problem

    BASF Increases Price of Kaolin
    Air Care/Environmental Fragrance
    AP/Deo
    Color Cosmetics
    Disinfectants
    Fine Fragrance
    Hair Care
    Household Cleaning
    I&I Marketplace
    Laundry Care
    Oral Care
    OTC/Medicated
    Packaging
    Personal Cleansers
    Skin Care
    Sun Care
    Testing

    Former L’Oréal Exec Joins Glossier

    P&G Emphasizes Small Actions at Home To Be More Sustainable

    L'Oréal's Sales Jump on Gains in China and E-Commerce

    Reckitt Seeks Germ-Killing Innovations

    PCPC Virtual Summit Features Legal & Regulatory Conference
    Lab Equipment
    Mixing
    Packaging
    Testing

    Admix Appoints COO to Advance Manufacturing, Supply Chain & Regulatory Compliance

    Tesco Eliminates Plastic Bags from Online Orders

    Hourglass To Launch Sustainable Cosmetics Line

    Carbon Data for Personal Care Labels

    L’Oréal Hong Kong Launches Cross-Brand Recycling Program
    Contract Manufacturing / Private Label Directory
    Buyer's Guide
    Add New Company
    Corporate Profiles
    International Buyers Guide Companies
    Praan Naturals

    Baralan USA

    Jeen International

    Lubrizol Life Science

    LipoTrue Inc.
    Live From Shows
    Meetings
    Webinars
    Snapshots
    • Magazine
      • Current / Back Issues
      • Features
      • Editorial
      • Columns
      • Digital Edition
      • eNewsletter Archive
      • Subscribe Now
      • Advertise Now
    • Breaking News
    • Formulary
    • Directories
      • Buyer's Guide
      • Contract Manufacturing / Private Label Directory
      • Corporate Profiles
      • Add Your Company
    • Raw Materials
      • Actives
      • Functional Ingredients
      • Pigments
      • Polymers
      • Preservatives
      • Surfactants
    • End-User
      • Air Care/Environmental Fragrance
      • AP/Deo
      • Color Cosmetics
      • Disinfectants
      • Fine Fragrance
      • Hair Care
      • Household Cleaning
      • I&I Marketplace
      • Laundry Care
      • Oral Care
      • OTC/Medicated
      • Packaging
      • Personal Cleansers
      • Skin Care
      • Sun Care
      • Testing
    • Packaging
      • Lab Equipment
      • Mixing
      • Packaging
      • Testing
    • Top Companies
      • International Top 30 Report
      • Top 50 Report
    • Online Exclusives
    • Experts Opinion
    • Slideshows
    • HappiTV
    • Videos
    • Podcasts
    • eBook
    • Infographics
    • Blog
    • Whitepapers
    • Surveys
      • R & D Salary Survey
      • Sales & Marketing Salary Survey
    • Job Banks
    • Events
      • Industry Events
      • Live from show Events
      • Webinars
    • About Us
      • About Us
      • Contact Us
      • Advertise With Us
      • Privacy Policy
      • Terms of Use
    Online Exclusives

    A Return to Castile Soap?

    A vegetable oil-based soap with an 80-year history of safety is a low-cost replacement for sulfated alcohols.

    A Return to Castile Soap?
    Related CONTENT
    • Former L’Oréal Exec Joins Glossier
    • Reckitt Seeks Germ-Killing Innovations
    • PCPC Virtual Summit Features Legal & Regulatory Conference
    • BASF Increases Price of Kaolin
    • Carlyle To Acquire Majority Stake in Beautycounter
    Tom Schoenberg , Personal Care Consultant04.04.21
    In today’s environment, producers of personal care products are continually challenged with new restrictions. The value of a product is no longer based on cost/performance, but whether it meets government safety requirements, which could be local, state or federal. Very often, the restrictions are not based on facts, but on potential risks. 
     
    For example, formaldehyde has been the most cost/effective preservative used in personal care for more than 80 years. Studies show that there is no evidence linking formaldehyde in cosmetics to cancer. Also, there is no official concentration at which formaldehyde is considered acceptable in personal care products. However, the name formaldehyde no longer appears on ingredient labels.1 The reason for this is that manufacturers prefer to avoid controversy. Once a chemical is deemed unsafe; e.g., formaldehyde, safety studies become irrelevant. Finding a replacement becomes the easier solution. Cost/performance becomes secondary.
     

    Surfactants


    Lately, several surface-active agents, (such as sulfates and nonionic), have been reported to be unsafe to the consumer. The following are three major surfactant classes in question:

    • Lauryl Sulfates (sodium, ammonium, TEA, etc.): This class of compounds has been the workhorse in personal care cleansers for over 70 years. In a concentrated form, (greater than 1.0%), if left on the skin for a long time, (24 hours) sulfates will cause irritation.2 In the diluted form, such as, washing hair, face, or hands, the surfactant is soon rinsed off and there is no risk.3
    Also, it has been rumored that “sulfates” are carcinogens but this myth is unfounded. Lauryl sulfates in a shampoo have no carcinogenic properties.3 At typical use levels, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and Cosmetic Ingredient Review Board (CIR) considered sulfates to be safe.

    • Ethoxylates: Ethoxylated compounds (fatty alcohols, amines, etc.) are the other workhorse surfactants used in personal cleansers for over 60 years. 1,4 dioxane (a potential human carcinogen), a byproduct of the ethoxylation process, is present at trace levels in laureth sulfates. The surfactant industry has significantly reduced the level to less than 10ppm.4 

    The FDA conducted a skin absorption study which showed 1,4 dioxane can penetrate huma skin when applied in a lotion. However, further research determined that 1,4 dioxane evaporates readily, further diminishing the already small amount available for skin absorption, even in products that remain on skin for hours.

    To date, there is no evidence that that 1,4 dioxane causes cancer in humans.4
     
    • Alkanol Amides: The alkanol amides have been used for over 80 years in cleansing products. When the amide is combined with an anionic surfactant; e.g., lauryl sulfate, the combination produces higher viscosity and improved foam quality (height and stability). In the process of formulating amides, there is a chance to form a nitrosamine with the amide or free amine. Cocamide DEA is often the source of diethanolamine which forms nitrosamine-n-nitrosethanolamine (NDELA). The nitosating agent can come from various sources. One common source is a preservative, 2-bromo-2-nitropropane 1,3-diol.

    Numerous studies link nitrosamines to cancer. Nitrosamines are listed as possible human carcinogens by the EPA, the International Agency for Research on Cancer, the US National Toxicity Program Report on Carcinogens and the California EPA Proposition 65 list of chemicals known to cause cancer or birth defects. Studies have also linked nitrosamines to developmental or reproductive toxicity, immunotoxicity, neurotoxicity and systemic toxicity.

    The FDA began watching personal care products for nitrosamine in 1979, and published a report stating that products containing nitrosamine could be seen as adulterated and subject to FDA enforcement. This led to a striking drop of NDELA from 150ppm to 3ppm.5 

    An example of the formation of a nitrosamine is show in the following mechanism:
     

    Mechanism of Nitrosamine Formation
    Although there are other suspected toxic compounds found in personal care cleansers, the major ones of concern today are formaldehyde, sulfates, ethoxylates and nitrosamines. None have shown to be connected to human cancer at normal use levels for cleansing products. Industries response to this dilemma is to replace the suspected surfactant with an alternative. Alternative surfactants, such as isethionates, or sarcosinates, have resulted in higher cost and lower performance. One alternative that has not been fully investigated is Castile soap.6,7


    Castile soap is a vegetable oil-based soap made in a style similar to that originating in the Castile region of Spain. Olive oil was the original vegetable oil used, however, eventually, olive oil was replaced with coconut oil. It is the most natural surfactant possible. The change in oils was most probably due to the better foaming properties of coconut oil soap, especially as coconut oil became easier to access.7

    In the 1930s, in Springfield Massachusetts, Dr. John H. Breck founded Breck Shampoo Company. Breck shampoo was the first major promotion for a Castile Soap Shampoo in the US. Breck’s ad campaign, which began in the 1930s and continued through the 1980s, featured beautiful illustrated portraits of “Breck Girls,” who were meant to look like real life women instead of glamourous models. Later, in the 1940s they dismissed other leading shampoos as “basically, synthetic detergents” promising that their natural (Castile soap) formula would not over strip the hair.9 Castile soap shampoo eventually gave way to the synthetics (sulfates) in the 1970s when Breck switched from Castile to synthetic.

    The Castile soap is a clear liquid around 40% active. It is prepared by the saponification of coconut or palm kernel oil (a triglyceride) with potassium hydroxide (note: sodium hydroxide will cause a cloudy product). The resulting compounds are potassium cocoate plus glycerin:
     
    Coconut (or palm kernel) oil + KOH = K cocoate + glycerin


    The glycerin is not removed. It provides a moisturizing effect to the skin.


    Other Additives



    When formulated, the coco sulfate is often combined with a foam booster and stabilizer which typically are amides or betaines. Cocamide DEA was the most common amide used, however, since DEA amides have been found to form nitrosamines, formulators have been searching to find alternatives. One replacement that appears promising, not based on DEA is: Cocamide DIPA (diisopropanolamide). It can often be used as a direct replacement for Cocamide DEA, without altering the performance of the product.
     
    The following model formula is based on Castile soap which is the main cleansing agent and is lower cost compared to other alternatives. This formula is: sulfate free, ethoxylate free, 1,4-dioxane free, formaldehyde free, DEA free, nitrosamine free:
     

    All-Purpose Cleaner
    Ingredients %Wt
    Surfonate 40  (Potassium cocoate - 40%) (General Surfactants, Joliet IL) 40.0
    Surfamide DIPA  (Cocamide DIPA) (General Surfactants, Joliet IL) 4.0
    Preservative/Fragrance q.s. q.s.
    Deionized water q.s.to 100

    Procedure:
    Combine the first two ingredients and water and blend. Heat to 40°C and blend until clear. Add preservative/fragrance and blend until clear. Cool and fill.
     
    This formula can be used as a base for a variety of products: shampoos, hard surface cleaners, liquid hand soaps, etc. Also, other additives may be included: e.g., aloe, hemp oil, biocides, proteins, etc.
     

    Conclusion


    Personal cleansing manufacturers continue to face more restrictions on raw materials allowed in their products. Alternatives for sulfated fatty alcohols and alkanol amides are more expensive and have mediocre performance. Castile soap, a proven success for more than 80 years, has been found to be a low-cost replacement for sulfated alcohols. Also, Castile soap, the most natural surfactant available,  is free of the claimed impurities, found in many personal care cleansers.

    The past may be the solution.

     
    References:
     1. Lisette Mejia, “Formaldehyde in Cosmetics: What’s the Verdict?”, Women’s Health, Oct. 2011.
     2. T.G. Schoenberg, “Sulfate-Free Cleansers”, Cosmetics and Toiletries, Dec. 2006, Vol 1`21, No. 12.
     3. "The Truth About Sulfates”, Best Health, July 2019.
     4. 1,4-Dioxane in Cosmetics: A Manufacturing Byproduct l EPA
     5. Shelley R. Kramer, “Healthy – Communications.com, 2009
     6. “How are Nitrosamines Formed? Bing
     7.  Schimmel Briefs, “Liquid Soaps”, April 1936
     8. Wikipedia “Castile Soap”.
     9. “How are nitrosamines formed?”, Bing
    10. Breck, “It’s claim to fame: Breck Girls”
    Related Searches
    • Surfactants
    • Personal Cleansers
    • Functional Ingredients
    Related Knowledge Center
    • Functional Ingredients
    • Surfactants
    • Personal Cleansers
    Suggested For You
    Beauty by the Numbers: Retinols & Alternatives Beauty by the Numbers: Retinols & Alternatives
    Beauty by the Numbers: Ingredient Innovations Beauty by the Numbers: Ingredient Innovations
    How 2020 Changed Aesthetics How 2020 Changed Aesthetics
    What’s Your Hydration IQ? What’s Your Hydration IQ?
    Fragrance Creators Association Celebrates P&G Executive Fragrance Creators Association Celebrates P&G Executive
    Former L’Oréal Exec Joins Glossier Former L’Oréal Exec Joins Glossier
    Reckitt Seeks Germ-Killing Innovations Reckitt Seeks Germ-Killing Innovations
    PCPC Virtual Summit Features Legal & Regulatory Conference PCPC Virtual Summit Features Legal & Regulatory Conference
    BASF Increases Price of Kaolin BASF Increases Price of Kaolin
    Carlyle To Acquire Majority Stake in Beautycounter Carlyle To Acquire Majority Stake in Beautycounter
    OTC Pain Relief QR Cream Debuts in US Market OTC Pain Relief QR Cream Debuts in US Market
    Elemis London Arrives at Bloomingdale’s Elemis London Arrives at Bloomingdale’s
    Guangzhou Builds Beauty Park To Woo L Guangzhou Builds Beauty Park To Woo L'Oréal, Estée Lauder
    What You’re Reading on Happi.com What You’re Reading on Happi.com
    IBA Stands Against Animal Testing of Cosmetics IBA Stands Against Animal Testing of Cosmetics

    Related Online Exclusives

    • Actives | Disinfectants | Functional Ingredients | Household Cleaning | Laundry Care | Surfactants
      Reckitt Seeks Germ-Killing Innovations

      Reckitt Seeks Germ-Killing Innovations

      Teams up with Halo to accelerate new product development.
      Tom Branna, Editorial Director 04.15.21

    • Functional Ingredients | Personal Cleansers
      Kao Promotes Hand Washing

      Kao Promotes Hand Washing

      Hygiene compliance is waning, even as COVID-19 cases are climbing in parts of the world. Through its MyKirei brand, Kao and TerraCycle are out to change that.
      Tom Branna, Editorial Director 04.11.21

    • Disinfectants | Household Cleaning | Personal Cleansers
      ‘Cleaning Is Caring’ Says ACI in New Pandemic Campaign

      ‘Cleaning Is Caring’ Says ACI in New Pandemic Campaign

      Online resources and PSA designed to help maintain critical cleaning behaviors adopted during the past year.
      Christine Esposito, Managing Editor 04.07.21


    • Functional Ingredients | Skin Care
      Stress Relief

      Stress Relief

      Nerves are on edge due to the pandemic, but Blossom & Stone’s CBD oil can help take the edge off.
      Tom Branna, Editorial Director 03.28.21

    • Actives | Color Cosmetics | Functional Ingredients
      Is It Better to Formulate Cosmetics with Natural Ingredients?

      Is It Better to Formulate Cosmetics with Natural Ingredients?

      Two experts weigh in on the debate between natural and synthetic ingredients.
      Charles Sternberg, Assistant Editor 03.24.21

    • Actives | Functional Ingredients | Hair Care | Personal Cleansers | Skin Care
      Protect the Cosmetic Supply Chain from Climate Change

      Protect the Cosmetic Supply Chain from Climate Change

      Integrated dual sourcing creates a climate change-proof supply chain that protects cosmetic manufacturers, says Sebastien Massard, Vantage Personal Care.
      Sebastien Massard, Vantage Personal Care 03.18.21


    • Personal Cleansers | Skin Care
      Boxes of Beauty & Wellness for Women Battling Cancer

      Boxes of Beauty & Wellness for Women Battling Cancer

      Chicago nonprofit organization founded by 28-year old Ashleigh Cortes helps women feel beautiful during the hard times of cancer treatment.
      Christine Esposito, Managing Editor 03.15.21

    • Functional Ingredients | Household Cleaning | Laundry Care | Surfactants
      P&G

      P&G's Supply Chain Strategies

      Procter & Gamble and Brenntag North America executives provide details on the lessons they’ve learned during the COVID-19 pandemic.
      Tom Branna , Editorial Director 03.11.21

    • Functional Ingredients | Hair Care | Surfactants
      American Crew Expands Hair Care Range

      American Crew Expands Hair Care Range

      Rolls out an enhanced lineup of shampoos and a conditioner for men.
      Tom Branna, Editorial Director 03.08.21


    • Household Cleaning | Personal Cleansers | Skin Care
      Pandemic Lifts Cleaning & Personal Care Sales in 2020

      Pandemic Lifts Cleaning & Personal Care Sales in 2020

      IRI/BCG’s Growth Leaders report shows COVID-10 shifts helped CPG industry grow 10.4%.
      Christine Esposito, Managing Editor 03.05.21

    • Actives | Color Cosmetics | Fine Fragrance | Functional Ingredients | Hair Care | Pigments | Preservatives | Skin Care
      Are Chemists the Rock Stars of Beauty?

      Are Chemists the Rock Stars of Beauty?

      With an emphasis on efficacy, cosmetic chemists have moved to center stage in the industry.
      Tom Branna, Editorial Director 02.25.21

    • Actives | Color Cosmetics | Functional Ingredients | Hair Care | Pigments | Skin Care
      Formulating for Inclusion

      Formulating for Inclusion

      Beauty suppliers and marketers, and dermatologists call for more products that meet the needs of Black consumers in this NYSCC webinar.
      Tom Branna, Editorial Director 02.19.21


    • Functional Ingredients | OTC/Medicated
      Pain Relief as Easy as C-B-D

      Pain Relief as Easy as C-B-D

      Nextraction has created an acidic cannabinoid lotion that provides topical pain relief.
      Tom Branna, Editorial Director 02.17.21

    • Actives | Color Cosmetics | Functional Ingredients | Hair Care | Personal Cleansers | Skin Care
      State of the Beauty Industry, Part I

      State of the Beauty Industry, Part I

      Technology helps marketers connect with consumers and track segment winners, insist analysts at CEW event.
      Nancy Jeffries, Contributing Editor 02.16.21

    • Disinfectants | Functional Ingredients | Household Cleaning | Laundry Care | Polymers | Surfactants
      The Future of Cleaning

      The Future of Cleaning

      The American Cleaning Institute looks at home cleaning during and after the pandemic.
      Christine Esposito, Managing Editor 02.10.21

    Trending
    • Sunscreen On The Spot
    • BASF Increases Price Of Kaolin
    • Henkel Appoints New EVP Of Beauty Care
    • Neutrogena Takes Action On Skin Health Disparities
    • Reckitt Seeks Germ-Killing Innovations
    Breaking News
    • Former L’Oréal Exec Joins Glossier
    • Evonik Highlights Solutions for Malodor Reduction
    • P&G Emphasizes Small Actions at Home To Be More Sustainable
    • L'Oréal's Sales Jump on Gains in China and E-Commerce
    • PCPC Virtual Summit Features Legal & Regulatory Conference
    View Breaking News >
    CURRENT ISSUE

    Household & Personal Care Wipes Spring 2021

    • A Conversation with the Responsible Flushing Alliance
    • Nice-Pak Meets Consumer Demands
    • Wipes Manufacturers Meet Demand Surge
    • Home Care Wipes: Sustainability in Sharper Focus as Cleaning Frenzy Simmers Following Pandemic
    • View More >

    Cookies help us to provide you with an excellent service. By using our website, you declare yourself in agreement with our use of cookies.
    You can obtain detailed information about the use of cookies on our website by clicking on "More information”.

    • About Us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms And Conditions
    • Contact Us

    follow us

    Subscribe
    Nutraceuticals World

    Latest Breaking News From Nutraceuticals World

    AstaReal Astaxanthin Ingredient Receives U.S. Patent Approval
    Study on Kemin’s DailyZz Botanical Blend Uncovers Sleep Quality, Next-Day Performance Benefits
    FDA’s Dr. Cara Welch Opening Speaker at the 9th AHPA Botanical Congress
    Coatings World

    Latest Breaking News From Coatings World

    Jebsen & Jessen, Innospec Sign Distribution Agreement
    IGL Coatings Announces Partnership in Finland
    Axalta Schedules 1Q 2021 Earnings Conference Call
    Medical Product Outsourcing

    Latest Breaking News From Medical Product Outsourcing

    Iterative Scopes Announces IBD-Focused Scientific Advisory Board
    Vicarious Surgical, D8 Holdings Corp. Combine Operations in $1.1 Billion Deal
    FDA Grants De Novo Clearance to Medtronic’s GI Genius Model
    Contract Pharma

    Latest Breaking News From Contract Pharma

    Bristol Myers Squibb Expands at Cambridge Crossing
    Amgen Completes Five Prime Acquisition
    Sartorius Expands in the UK
    Beauty Packaging

    Latest Breaking News From Beauty Packaging

    Former L’Oréal Exec Joins Glossier
    Lancôme Reveals New Global Sustainability Program
    First-Ever Skincare Line Focuses on Iron To Prevent Aging
    Happi

    Latest Breaking News From Happi

    Fragrance Creators Association Celebrates P&G Executive
    What You're Reading on Happi.com
    Former L’Oréal Exec Joins Glossier
    Ink World

    Latest Breaking News From Ink World

    Kumon North America Adds Speedmaster XL 106 from Heidelberg
    SE-DA Invests in Kornit Presto S
    Acrylic Resins Market Worth $21.9 Billion by 2025: MarketsandMarkets
    Label & Narrow Web

    Latest Breaking News From Label & Narrow Web

    TLMI reveals Eugene Singer Award winners at Virtual Spring Summit
    Monadnock Paper Mills joins SGP
    ACTEGA helps converter reach sustainability goals
    Nonwovens Industry

    Latest Breaking News From Nonwovens Industry

    Albaad to Add Natural-Based Line in Israel
    First Quality to Discontinue Tampon Operations
    Jessup Installs New Era Coating and Laminating Line
    Orthopedic Design & Technology

    Latest Breaking News From Orthopedic Design & Technology

    BioMagnetic Sciences Names President and CEO
    Mainstay Medical Launches ReActiv8 in Australia
    Biogennix Rolls Out Agilon Strip Bone Graft
    Printed Electronics Now

    Latest Breaking News From Printed Electronics Now

    Virtual ASMC 2021 Spotlights Advanced Semiconductor Manufacturing Excellence
    LG Display Cuts Down CO2-eq Emissions by 3 Million Tons in 2020
    European Commission's Innovation Radar Acknowledges 3 ARMOR Innovations

    Copyright © 2021 Rodman Media. All rights reserved. Use of this constitutes acceptance of our privacy policy The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Rodman Media.

    AD BLOCKER DETECTED

    Our website is made possible by displaying online advertisements to our visitors.
    Please consider supporting us by disabling your ad blocker.


    FREE SUBSCRIPTION Already a subscriber? Login